Sayid *is* Evil

When Yoko hands Sayid the knife he says "If there is still good in you, then prove it." I think only a good person can harm Fake Locke (and perhaps only an evil person, Ben, could kill Jacob). So it could be Sayid wasn't sent to his death after all.

Comments

[Michael Sippey]

Hmmm. If this is the case then there is a way for someone to kill Fake Locke / smokey? And who is left that is purely good? Jack? Nah. Kate? Nah (and .tiff would have a heart attack if she turned out to be the hero). Sun? Maybe?

I loved Sundown. Such a great episode.

[David Jacobs]

Reading Lostpedia right now actually, and they posit the opposite
theory. That only someone evil can kill Fake Locke, and only someone
good (Ben) could kill Jacob.

http://lostpedia.wikia.com/wiki/Sundown/Theories